In the latest issue of NIRI’s IR Update, Evan Pondel examines a new wrinkle in earnings season: prediction markets such as Kalshi now let traders bet on which words executives will say on upcoming earnings calls, at companies from General Motors to Netflix.
Drawing on a Duke University working paper by William J. Mayew and Boyan Zhu, which studied more than 1,400 contracts tied to more than 100 earnings calls, the article asks whether investor relations teams should be watching these prices.
What the research found
- Market prices predicted executive language about as well as a model built from a company’s own past calls, press releases and filings. Combining the two added little.
- Prices did well on scripted remarks but barely beat chance on the Q&A.
- Many contracts trade thinly, suggesting much of the activity is closer to entertainment than insight.
The risks for IR teams
- Appearing to cater to speculators at the expense of other investors.
- Executives can effectively settle a bet simply by saying a word, as happened on a 2025 Coinbase call.
- Private conversations that leak planned language create insider-trading exposure.
- Regulators, including the CFTC, are still weighing how these markets should work.
What to do about it
- Treat prices as a cheap, limited read on retail interest, not a guide to messaging.
- Revisit quiet-period policies so they address prediction markets explicitly.
- Don’t tailor disclosure to bettors.
The bottom line: the best predictor of what executives will say next quarter is still what the company said last quarter.